book report 3
This is my book report for my latest book: So You're Thinking about Homeschooling
Highlights:
Basically this is a book that takes 15 different families, and gives them the opportunity to explain why they chose to home school, how they do it, and the pro's and con's for each family. I will first write the things/quotes that most stuck out to me as I read through the family stories.
*I understand what must be swirling around in your mind if you are even considering education your children at home: Is it even legal? How much will it cost? Can I really teach my children? Will I ruin them for life? What about what I don't know ? What about what I don't know that I don't know? Will my ids become social misfits? what will my mother in-law think? Will I go crazy in the process? What if I need to work outside the home? Must I have twelve children, raise goats, and bake my own bread? Where do I start?...You've already started. Think about it (all that you have done thus far) What makes parents think that once our children reach the age of five, we are no longer capable of teaching them?
*One benefit: Not that I am that smart, but I know my children and I know how they learn best.
*Many parents who choose to home school do so because they want to be the primary influence in their kids' lives. Indeed, our responsibility--I like to think of it as our privilege--is to train our children and shape their character. You can't schedule a 'teachable moment,' and the less time you spend with your children, the fewer opportunities you will have to seize these moments when they present themselves. We believe that discipline is foundational--not only for a positive home school experience but also for a successful life experience--and I don't want to leave it up to someone else to make sure my children develop good character traits in addition to good study habits. I'm not just referring to correcting the children when they make poor choices; we also try to catch them making good choices and point out when they demonstrate obedience, selflessness, diligence, initiative, honesty and the like.
*I wouldn't be honest if I didn't tell you some days, when the alarm rings, I'm tempted to pull the covers over my head and call in sick. I've been homeschooling for fifteen years and I "quit" about one every year. But then I stop and remember why we started homeschooling in the first place. Do I really want them learning evolution is fact, politically correct agendas, rewritten history, tolerance as a subject, and how to put on a condom? No, I want my children to marvel at God's creation and seek out answers as to how it all works together. I want them to understand the power of words and be capable of reaching their potential for influence, both written and spoken, for the good of mankind. I want them to appreciate order and understand the mathematical formulas for achieving it. i want them to know where they are going by learning from those who have gone before them.
*How do you home school with a newborn, a toddler, and a preschooler in the house? My philosophy is, if you can't beat em, ask em to join you! It is truly amazing how much they pick up just by being in the room while you teach.
*In the beginning I was tempted to jump through all of the traditional academic hoops until I stopped and asked myself, What do I really want for my daughters and sons when they grow up and leave this house? I want my sons to become stalwart leaders with strong servant's hearts. I want to train them to be good husbands by requiring them to treat their sisters with respect and care. Making sure they have the mind-set and practical skills to be the providers, protectors and spiritual heads of their homes. I want to model respect for my husband in front of all my children, but especially for my daughters. I want to prepare them for higher education, should they choose that path. At the same time I want to show them by example that being a stay-at-home mom is perhaps the most rewarding vocation in the world.
*I guess alot depends on how you measure success. My children still believe I'm the best mother in the world, that their father is wise, and that it is cool to live in the same house with their best friends. Homeschooling does not create perfect children who never compete with one another or squabble, but it can create close ties between family members who naturally come to know each other better because of the time they spend together. that is what I call success. Family identity--relationships--connectedness.
*A quote from John Taylor Gatto's acceptance speech when he was awarded the Teacher of the Year in 1990:
What can be done? First we need ferocious national debate that doesn't quit, day after day, year after year. We need to scream and argue about this school thing until it is fixed or broken beyond repair, one or the other. If we can fix it, fine; if we cannot then the success of homeschooling shows a different road to take that has great promise. Pouring the money we now poor into family education might kill two birds with one stone, repairing families as it repairs children.
*This homeschooling in a nutshell--teaching real life skills with real life as our classroom.
*My decision to leave was not based so much on the negatives of government-run school as much as it was the benefits of teaching my own children.
*You can ignore the whole socialization controversy. It's a non-issue. I like the Mary Beth Nelsen quote that's popular among homeschoolers. When asked if socialization was a problem for her family, she answered, "We did tend to over socialize when we first started homeschooling, but I think we have it under control now."
For me the big takeaways:
1) Homeschooling is alot bigger than I thought. In fact many of my stereotypes of the whole thing are based on what I have heard rather than seen. I was surprised on closer look and after reading this book to discover that there are a growing number of homeschoolers out there and they aren't all christian! The reasons for homeschooling are vast--and the resources are tremendous for those who choose to do it.
2)Their stats are impressive (regarding smarts;) and the socialization issue is kind of moot point for people who are diligent to introduce their kids to all kinds of people in the community and world through service, fun, and activities. Most of the kids--are very well adjusted.
3) We are all homeschoolers. Some may delegate a bigger chunk to 'teachers', but really most all parents are working on a daily basis with their kids on some area of life to gain better understanding and knowledge.
4) There isn't a 'right' decision, but rather a 'right' for your family. You don't have to be in a certain 'camp' (thinking your camp is better than someone elses) or compare your decision to others in order to 'feel' good about your choice.
Good book though: I highly recommend it to anyone who is considering homeschooling or just wants to have a better understanding of what it means (and doesn't mean).
Highlights:
Basically this is a book that takes 15 different families, and gives them the opportunity to explain why they chose to home school, how they do it, and the pro's and con's for each family. I will first write the things/quotes that most stuck out to me as I read through the family stories.
*I understand what must be swirling around in your mind if you are even considering education your children at home: Is it even legal? How much will it cost? Can I really teach my children? Will I ruin them for life? What about what I don't know ? What about what I don't know that I don't know? Will my ids become social misfits? what will my mother in-law think? Will I go crazy in the process? What if I need to work outside the home? Must I have twelve children, raise goats, and bake my own bread? Where do I start?...You've already started. Think about it (all that you have done thus far) What makes parents think that once our children reach the age of five, we are no longer capable of teaching them?
*One benefit: Not that I am that smart, but I know my children and I know how they learn best.
*Many parents who choose to home school do so because they want to be the primary influence in their kids' lives. Indeed, our responsibility--I like to think of it as our privilege--is to train our children and shape their character. You can't schedule a 'teachable moment,' and the less time you spend with your children, the fewer opportunities you will have to seize these moments when they present themselves. We believe that discipline is foundational--not only for a positive home school experience but also for a successful life experience--and I don't want to leave it up to someone else to make sure my children develop good character traits in addition to good study habits. I'm not just referring to correcting the children when they make poor choices; we also try to catch them making good choices and point out when they demonstrate obedience, selflessness, diligence, initiative, honesty and the like.
*I wouldn't be honest if I didn't tell you some days, when the alarm rings, I'm tempted to pull the covers over my head and call in sick. I've been homeschooling for fifteen years and I "quit" about one every year. But then I stop and remember why we started homeschooling in the first place. Do I really want them learning evolution is fact, politically correct agendas, rewritten history, tolerance as a subject, and how to put on a condom? No, I want my children to marvel at God's creation and seek out answers as to how it all works together. I want them to understand the power of words and be capable of reaching their potential for influence, both written and spoken, for the good of mankind. I want them to appreciate order and understand the mathematical formulas for achieving it. i want them to know where they are going by learning from those who have gone before them.
*How do you home school with a newborn, a toddler, and a preschooler in the house? My philosophy is, if you can't beat em, ask em to join you! It is truly amazing how much they pick up just by being in the room while you teach.
*In the beginning I was tempted to jump through all of the traditional academic hoops until I stopped and asked myself, What do I really want for my daughters and sons when they grow up and leave this house? I want my sons to become stalwart leaders with strong servant's hearts. I want to train them to be good husbands by requiring them to treat their sisters with respect and care. Making sure they have the mind-set and practical skills to be the providers, protectors and spiritual heads of their homes. I want to model respect for my husband in front of all my children, but especially for my daughters. I want to prepare them for higher education, should they choose that path. At the same time I want to show them by example that being a stay-at-home mom is perhaps the most rewarding vocation in the world.
*I guess alot depends on how you measure success. My children still believe I'm the best mother in the world, that their father is wise, and that it is cool to live in the same house with their best friends. Homeschooling does not create perfect children who never compete with one another or squabble, but it can create close ties between family members who naturally come to know each other better because of the time they spend together. that is what I call success. Family identity--relationships--connectedness.
*A quote from John Taylor Gatto's acceptance speech when he was awarded the Teacher of the Year in 1990:
What can be done? First we need ferocious national debate that doesn't quit, day after day, year after year. We need to scream and argue about this school thing until it is fixed or broken beyond repair, one or the other. If we can fix it, fine; if we cannot then the success of homeschooling shows a different road to take that has great promise. Pouring the money we now poor into family education might kill two birds with one stone, repairing families as it repairs children.
*This homeschooling in a nutshell--teaching real life skills with real life as our classroom.
*My decision to leave was not based so much on the negatives of government-run school as much as it was the benefits of teaching my own children.
*You can ignore the whole socialization controversy. It's a non-issue. I like the Mary Beth Nelsen quote that's popular among homeschoolers. When asked if socialization was a problem for her family, she answered, "We did tend to over socialize when we first started homeschooling, but I think we have it under control now."
For me the big takeaways:
1) Homeschooling is alot bigger than I thought. In fact many of my stereotypes of the whole thing are based on what I have heard rather than seen. I was surprised on closer look and after reading this book to discover that there are a growing number of homeschoolers out there and they aren't all christian! The reasons for homeschooling are vast--and the resources are tremendous for those who choose to do it.
2)Their stats are impressive (regarding smarts;) and the socialization issue is kind of moot point for people who are diligent to introduce their kids to all kinds of people in the community and world through service, fun, and activities. Most of the kids--are very well adjusted.
3) We are all homeschoolers. Some may delegate a bigger chunk to 'teachers', but really most all parents are working on a daily basis with their kids on some area of life to gain better understanding and knowledge.
4) There isn't a 'right' decision, but rather a 'right' for your family. You don't have to be in a certain 'camp' (thinking your camp is better than someone elses) or compare your decision to others in order to 'feel' good about your choice.
Good book though: I highly recommend it to anyone who is considering homeschooling or just wants to have a better understanding of what it means (and doesn't mean).
Comments