education options
For those of you know us--you know Ben and I have been praying about this school decision for months. With Caleb starting Kindergarten next week (!) the time has come to make the decision. What will we do? Public, Private or Home School?? We have not taken this decision lightly--and we have done alot of praying,researching, interviewing,visiting schools and debating all our options.
Here is the gist of our 9 months of research:
Good kids come from good schools.
Good kids come from bad schools.
Good kids come from public schools.
Good kids come from private schools.
Good kids come from being homeschooled.
In addition we also have learned:
Bad kids come from good schools.
Bad kids come from bad schools.
Bad kids come from public schools.
Bad kids come from private schools.
Bad kids come from being homeschooled.
*Note* You can replace just about any adjective (smart, rebellious, socialized, funny, successful, creative, immoral, lazy, hard-working,etc) for good/bad in the above combinations and come out with the same results!
Basically: There is no magic formula--there are no guarantees. But there is a God who knows our situation, our kids, and their needs--and he is more than willing to give wisdom to those who seek it.
IN addition to the previous research we have also learned:
Most people fall into a camp: Camp Public, Camp Private, Camp Homeschool--and often more than not--they feel their camp is the best camp--and have many reasons to prove their theory. And often, more than not--they have good reasons--and good results to prove such a theory.
In fact I know some wonderful parents--and wonderful children--all choosing different paths--and all the paths working for them. Now, each path--whether private, public or home school--has both advantages and disadvantages. I could write an entire post about this--but I will spare you.
When it comes down to it--we have prayed, layed it before God, reasoned it out--weighed the options and spent 9 months wavering back and forth--And now we are asking God--in a slightly loud voice-- WHAT DO YOU WANT US TO DO??? AND THEN, help us DO IT.
Ironically-- 9 months ago--as we were contemplating our options and wholeheartedly seeking the Lord--a passage of scripture stuck out to me--enough for me to write it down and study it at the time. Basically, the chunk comes from Jeremiah 40:1-6. Jeremiah was a prophet of God--from Israel. He was sent by God to tell his people that God was going to bring disaster upon them--not prosperity. Well, you can imagine that if you told your family--your own people that kind of news--it wouldn't go well. He basically said, God is going to let the Babylonians destroy you (us!). (*note* The Babylonians were a terrible people). But Jeremiah--(surely) knowing this wouldn't go over well--obeyed God anyway and told his people the truth.
Now the Babylonians--were actually thrilled with this report. They would defeat Israel! So they were quite respectful of Jeremiah (I mean he did predict their victory! And they did win) even though he was not one of them.
So when all the Israelites ( Jeremiah included--along with Gods people) were found bound in chains, and being carried to exhile--a commander of the Babylonian guard found Jeremiah and said this:
When the commander of the guard found Jeremiah, he said to him, The Lord your God decreed this disaster for this place. And now the Lord has brought it about; he has done just as he said he would. All this happened because your people sinned against the Lord and did not obey him. But today I am freeing you (Jeremiah) from the chains on your wrists. Come with me to Babylon, if you like, and I will look after you; but if you do not want to, then don't come. Look, the whole country lies before you; go wherever you please." ....and as Jeremiah turned to go--another commander said to him, ..."or go anywhere else you please."
So Jeremiah had a few choices--he was essentially free to go wherever he wanted. He could go live a plush life--respected by the Babylonians--but he knew he would not be with his people. Or he could go back to his people, and yet live in hardship and exhile--not to mention they would probably hate him for predicting this terrible thing that happened to them.
Regardless of his choice--the point--he had the freedom to choose--and each option had it's pro's and con's. And you can bet that Jeremiah knew--whatever he chose--God would be with him.
Ironic though that God layed this chunk of Scripture on my heart 9 months ago and this week I have come back to it. The in between time-- I have another 5 other pages of thoughts, quotes and scripture not to mention I've read about 5 books regarding this school stuff. In addition I have had endless conversations with friends, family, teachers, schools...(I apologize if you have had to endure these:)) But after all of that--I realize that peace in a decision like this comes not from endless reasoning--but from going in the direction you feel God leading--whether that decision seems difficult or even makes sense--to you or others.
In some of our researching we have found many interesting thoughts on the issues of education and choosing an education option. We especially liked what Gregg Harris (homeschooling dad and pioneer of the HS movement) had to say in a letter to his son, Josh Harris(author of I kissed dating goodbye)
Educational choices have always been a matter of parental responsibility, not of some extra-biblical standard. Every householder should make an informed decision before God. All should research their local schools, public and private and become fully convinced in the way in which he (or she) decides to use his God-given liberty under the Lordship of Christ to bear the best and most abundant fruit he can for the glory of God.
The only moral issue at stake is whether we are willing to walk in the obedience of our faith in God and His will as we understand it from the Scriptures. Though wisdom and foolishness are called into play, there is no moral superiority to be found in any one educational option. Though dilligence is required of all three options, only our labor in Christ will not be in vain. Then, as the relative fruit of each option is put on display in time, may we all be humble enough to change our ways as needed in order to bear even better fruit for God.
Not all options seem to be equally fruitful thus far. But as a long-time home-schooling father and Christian home-schooling advocate I can honestly say that every option, including home schooling has its problems (as you well know). So, pick your problems, and by the grace of God deal with those problems as they arise. Our family has chosen the problems that come with home schooling. But, as you have said, we pray for all of our fellow parents and their children that God will mercifully bless their efforts to be faithful. We are all one in the body of Christ and that should allow us to support one another wholeheartedly in spite of our differing convictions on how to educate our children.
Exhausted, last week--Ben and I sat on the couch and prayed that the Lord would make the path very clear to us--shutting all doors except the one we should walk through. And he did--just in the nick of time. This year--we will be a homeschooling family. Next year....who knows...only time and prayer will tell.
The very last thing I will share about what we have learned in our exploration of options: Good teachers are amazing people. Public school--private school, and homeschool. They play a huge role in shaping and molding an entire generation. They are pouring their lives and abilities into young people and making a difference for the Lord. They definitely deserve more money, more appreciation and more prayers!
Here is the gist of our 9 months of research:
Good kids come from good schools.
Good kids come from bad schools.
Good kids come from public schools.
Good kids come from private schools.
Good kids come from being homeschooled.
In addition we also have learned:
Bad kids come from good schools.
Bad kids come from bad schools.
Bad kids come from public schools.
Bad kids come from private schools.
Bad kids come from being homeschooled.
*Note* You can replace just about any adjective (smart, rebellious, socialized, funny, successful, creative, immoral, lazy, hard-working,etc) for good/bad in the above combinations and come out with the same results!
Basically: There is no magic formula--there are no guarantees. But there is a God who knows our situation, our kids, and their needs--and he is more than willing to give wisdom to those who seek it.
IN addition to the previous research we have also learned:
Most people fall into a camp: Camp Public, Camp Private, Camp Homeschool--and often more than not--they feel their camp is the best camp--and have many reasons to prove their theory. And often, more than not--they have good reasons--and good results to prove such a theory.
In fact I know some wonderful parents--and wonderful children--all choosing different paths--and all the paths working for them. Now, each path--whether private, public or home school--has both advantages and disadvantages. I could write an entire post about this--but I will spare you.
When it comes down to it--we have prayed, layed it before God, reasoned it out--weighed the options and spent 9 months wavering back and forth--And now we are asking God--in a slightly loud voice-- WHAT DO YOU WANT US TO DO??? AND THEN, help us DO IT.
Ironically-- 9 months ago--as we were contemplating our options and wholeheartedly seeking the Lord--a passage of scripture stuck out to me--enough for me to write it down and study it at the time. Basically, the chunk comes from Jeremiah 40:1-6. Jeremiah was a prophet of God--from Israel. He was sent by God to tell his people that God was going to bring disaster upon them--not prosperity. Well, you can imagine that if you told your family--your own people that kind of news--it wouldn't go well. He basically said, God is going to let the Babylonians destroy you (us!). (*note* The Babylonians were a terrible people). But Jeremiah--(surely) knowing this wouldn't go over well--obeyed God anyway and told his people the truth.
Now the Babylonians--were actually thrilled with this report. They would defeat Israel! So they were quite respectful of Jeremiah (I mean he did predict their victory! And they did win) even though he was not one of them.
So when all the Israelites ( Jeremiah included--along with Gods people) were found bound in chains, and being carried to exhile--a commander of the Babylonian guard found Jeremiah and said this:
When the commander of the guard found Jeremiah, he said to him, The Lord your God decreed this disaster for this place. And now the Lord has brought it about; he has done just as he said he would. All this happened because your people sinned against the Lord and did not obey him. But today I am freeing you (Jeremiah) from the chains on your wrists. Come with me to Babylon, if you like, and I will look after you; but if you do not want to, then don't come. Look, the whole country lies before you; go wherever you please." ....and as Jeremiah turned to go--another commander said to him, ..."or go anywhere else you please."
So Jeremiah had a few choices--he was essentially free to go wherever he wanted. He could go live a plush life--respected by the Babylonians--but he knew he would not be with his people. Or he could go back to his people, and yet live in hardship and exhile--not to mention they would probably hate him for predicting this terrible thing that happened to them.
Regardless of his choice--the point--he had the freedom to choose--and each option had it's pro's and con's. And you can bet that Jeremiah knew--whatever he chose--God would be with him.
Ironic though that God layed this chunk of Scripture on my heart 9 months ago and this week I have come back to it. The in between time-- I have another 5 other pages of thoughts, quotes and scripture not to mention I've read about 5 books regarding this school stuff. In addition I have had endless conversations with friends, family, teachers, schools...(I apologize if you have had to endure these:)) But after all of that--I realize that peace in a decision like this comes not from endless reasoning--but from going in the direction you feel God leading--whether that decision seems difficult or even makes sense--to you or others.
In some of our researching we have found many interesting thoughts on the issues of education and choosing an education option. We especially liked what Gregg Harris (homeschooling dad and pioneer of the HS movement) had to say in a letter to his son, Josh Harris(author of I kissed dating goodbye)
Educational choices have always been a matter of parental responsibility, not of some extra-biblical standard. Every householder should make an informed decision before God. All should research their local schools, public and private and become fully convinced in the way in which he (or she) decides to use his God-given liberty under the Lordship of Christ to bear the best and most abundant fruit he can for the glory of God.
The only moral issue at stake is whether we are willing to walk in the obedience of our faith in God and His will as we understand it from the Scriptures. Though wisdom and foolishness are called into play, there is no moral superiority to be found in any one educational option. Though dilligence is required of all three options, only our labor in Christ will not be in vain. Then, as the relative fruit of each option is put on display in time, may we all be humble enough to change our ways as needed in order to bear even better fruit for God.
Not all options seem to be equally fruitful thus far. But as a long-time home-schooling father and Christian home-schooling advocate I can honestly say that every option, including home schooling has its problems (as you well know). So, pick your problems, and by the grace of God deal with those problems as they arise. Our family has chosen the problems that come with home schooling. But, as you have said, we pray for all of our fellow parents and their children that God will mercifully bless their efforts to be faithful. We are all one in the body of Christ and that should allow us to support one another wholeheartedly in spite of our differing convictions on how to educate our children.
Exhausted, last week--Ben and I sat on the couch and prayed that the Lord would make the path very clear to us--shutting all doors except the one we should walk through. And he did--just in the nick of time. This year--we will be a homeschooling family. Next year....who knows...only time and prayer will tell.
The very last thing I will share about what we have learned in our exploration of options: Good teachers are amazing people. Public school--private school, and homeschool. They play a huge role in shaping and molding an entire generation. They are pouring their lives and abilities into young people and making a difference for the Lord. They definitely deserve more money, more appreciation and more prayers!
Comments
You are right, it is easy to become prideful about the choices that one makes, feeling as though it is the only way or the "right" way. It is humbling to learn that just because something works for me, doesn't mean it works for everyone! Maybe, as Christians, we are guilty of that because we know THE way THE truth and THE light.
Yet, when it comes to your educational choices, the condition of your marriage, cleanliness and organization of your home, etc., no one does it perfectly. Thankfully, we are all covered by His grace.
The key to homeschooling--or anything, for that matter--is to bask in the grace He gives us for each day, and to remember that His mercies are new each morning.
Jenn